Self-Criticism / Perfectionism

By Noah Rubinstein, LMHC (he/him)

March 1, 2026 One of the most common ways people try to protect themselves from rejection and shame is through harsh self-criticism, essentially becoming their own worst critic. In some people, the inner critic develops as a protective part of the psyche that relentlessly judges and pressures, believing that if it can push, improve, or perfect us, we might avoid the disapproval and criticism of others, and the painful feelings of shame we once experienced, often early in life.

In this way, the critic chides, scolds, and berates us, frequently echoing the tone, posture, or language of parents, teachers, caregivers, or other authority figures who once disapproved of us or held impossibly high expectations. Whether expressed as criticism, pressure, or an unrelenting demand to “do better,” the inner critic forms as a response to earlier pain, trying in its own way to keep us safe from ever feeling those same awful feelings again.

When working with the inner critic in therapy, or with any other protective part, the goal is not to control it, silence it, or make it disappear. Instead, the work is more like emotional aikido. Rather than resisting or fighting the critic, we move toward it with curiosity and openness. As we do, the critic often begins to soften on its own. When we listen carefully, we discover what it wants for us, how it developed, and why it has worked so tirelessly on our behalf.

Invariably, as people come to understand the intention behind their inner critic, they begin to feel genuine appreciation for its extraordinary efforts to protect them. This new relationship with the critic becomes a doorway to healing the underlying wounds it has been guarding against. As that deeper healing takes place, the critic discovers that it no longer needs to work as hard as it once did. Over time, it can relax, and the person comes to experience a felt sense of being already enough, worthy, and fully acceptable as they are.

Sometimes, rather than a harsh inner critic, people have a highly active Perfectionistic Part. This part may push relentlessly toward flawlessness, productivity, or achievement, but without the constant barrage of overt self-criticism. Instead of berating, it motivates through pressure, high standards, and an ever-moving finish line. While its tone may be quieter or even encouraging, its underlying goal is often the same: to prevent rejection, failure, or shame by ensuring nothing is ever done “wrong.”

Working with a Perfectionistic Part is very similar to working with an inner critic. In therapy, we get to know this part with the same curiosity and respect, learning what it fears, what it hopes to prevent, and what it wants for the person. As trust develops and the original pain beneath the perfectionism is addressed, this part, too, can begin to soften. Freed from the burden of having to keep everything perfect, it can transform into a source of discernment, care, and healthy striving rather than relentless pressure.

Back to What I Help People With